Editing v0.31 Talk:Soap

I was under the impression that soap is bugged very badly right now.  Specifically, with the introduction of the new "glob" unit, soap is now produced in globs, but every potential use for soap is programmed to use bars.  This can be easily fixed:


Open reaction_other.txt in your save raws and/or default raws folder and change

Code: [Select]

[PRODUCT:100:1:GLOB:NONE:GET_MATERIAL_FROM_REAGENT:B:SOAP_MAT]

to-->

Code: [Select]

[PRODUCT:100:1:BAR:NONE:GET_MATERIAL_FROM_REAGENT:B:SOAP_MAT]

: With the bugfix version, soap is now in bars. --[[User:Zombiejustice|Zombiejustice]] 16:44, 9 April 2010 (UTC)


Thanks, Fox the Undead, http://www.bay12games.com/forum/index.php?topic=52996.0

If someone wants to post this on the main page, go ahead.  I'm still new here and I don't want to mess anything up.

-[[User:Theothersteve7|Theothersteve7]] 15:23, 7 April 2010 (UTC)

== This command must be entered through the Manager ==

Why doesn't the Soap Maker allow you to add the task directly?  Isn't this a bug missing from the Bug section of the page?

[[User:Neebat|Neebat]] 18:08, 21 June 2010 (UTC)


== Is Soap needed? ==

More specifically what happens if your hospital zone has no soap?
:Wounded dwarves won't be cleaned, which (probably) leads to an infection which is very bad. --[[Special:Contributions/dUMBELLS|dUMBELLS]] 05:31, 14 April 2010 (UTC)
::Actually they will be cleaned but only with water. It probably is more likely they will get an infection without soap. --[[Special:Contributions/202.124.123.107|202.124.123.107]] 03:01, 12 May 2010 (UTC)
:::Yeah, this happened to me, where I had a legendary mason who was injured in a cave-in, and was all patched up and casted at the hospital, but went from faint to pale and then died while resting. The announcement said he died from infection. I decided to try making soap after that one.
::::There's the infection fighting properties, but also dwarfs can get a "wonderful soapy bath" good thought --[[Special:Contributions/69.151.63.186|69.151.63.186]] 19:39, 12 April 2011 (UTC)

==Soap Quality Question==

Does soap have quality modifiers (like food and statues) or not (like coke and cut gems)? That is to say, do I need to pay attention to the skill levels of my soapmakers?

Well soap is a type of bar, so like other bars, it shouldn't have a quality level. [[Special:Contributions/94.9.171.251|94.9.171.251]] 22:40, 26 February 2011 (UTC)

== Buckets? ==
My dwarves put lye in buckets, but the soaper cancels, asking for lye bearing '''barrel'''.

Will they fill the lye in barrels when i have 5? or 10? --[[Special:Contributions/92.202.121.225|92.202.121.225]] 00:02, 10 April 2010 (UTC)
:They'll do it once there's an empty (or lye-containing) barrel sitting in a Food stockpile which accepts lye, though it may take a while before a dwarf takes the initiative to actually '''do''' it. A single barrel should be able to hold up to 100 units of lye, assuming it hasn't changed since 40d. --[[User:Quietust|Quietust]] 00:06, 10 April 2010 (UTC)
::I think I've discovered a bit of a bug in regards to this.  Dwarves use buckets to clean patients and provide water to wounded & prisoners... but this doesn't use up the entire bucket of water, leaving you with a bucket containing "stagnant water [x]".  Lye-makers don't care that the bucket has water in it, so they go ahead and put lye into it, giving you a bucket with both water and lye.  Then, said bucket sits in your ashery.  Why?  Dwarves who want to empty out the lye see the water and forget it, while dwarves who want to use up the water see the lye and forget that.  It might've been fixed after .31.04 (what I'm playing with right now). --[[User:DeMatt|DeMatt]] 21:52, 8 June 2010 (UTC)

:::I'm running .12 and have the same problem.  [[Special:Contributions/202.156.10.234|202.156.10.234]] 01:37, 3 October 2010 (UTC)

::: And again in .14 an .15 (though I hadn't figured out how the buckets were getting filled). What's worse, you can't dump the liquid any more than you can dump blood or ichor out of a barrel. --[[User:Romeofalling|Romeofalling]] 07:24, 4 October 2010 (UTC)
::::Still an issue in .16; I'm attempting to get around this by designating a burrow containing an ash stockpile, an empty barrel stockpile, and an empty bucket stockpile, in addition to the ashery, wood furnace, and carpenter's shop.  We'll see how this works. [[User:Ademrudin|Ademrudin]] 04:52, 3 November 2010 (UTC)
:::::Note: I believe this is fixed in .18 [[User:Ademrudin|Ademrudin]] 19:08, 8 December 2010 (UTC)

::::::Response to the note up there: no, its not fixed, i run the .18, and i have tons of bucket with both (lye and water) sitting in my lye workshop. :/

::::::Right, same with me.. Eventually used the Manager option and spammed Barrels, Ash, and Buckets until it worked.  Lots (20-30) of errors about no lye-bearing barrels even while waiting for the Manager option.  Seems bugged to me.  I think there should be a note on this page, if someone can find a citation in the DF Forums.  [[Special:Contributions/71.181.41.95|71.181.41.95]]

::::::I'm playing .25, I have had this problem but was able to dump the water from the buckets. This is possibly to do with playing on a glacier, thus turning the lye to 'frozen lye' until it is brought in to the warmer lower-fortress. --[[Special:Contributions/213.121.247.101|213.121.247.101]] 10:40, 17 June 2011 (UTC)
:::::::Forbid the water (but '''not''' the lye or the buckets themselves), then order the buckets to be hauled to the trade depot. --[[User:Quietust|Quietust]] 13:21, 17 June 2011 (UTC)

:A straight-forward fix for this problem is simply purchasing the finished barrels of lye from the embark and the caravan menus. [[Special:Contributions/71.181.41.95|71.181.41.95]] 01:20, 18 January 2011 (UTC)

== Pets ==

I have several pets (cats and racoons seen so far) carrying around bars of soap in their mouths. I am not sure if it is their "cleaning" task or if it is something else. [[User:Matakuka|Matakuka]] 13:04, 12 April 2010 (UTC)

==how much soap is used==
After using some soap does it get used up?

==Still bugged?==
I'm having no problems with soap in my fortress, I've got soap, I've got dorfs and pets, but no error message spam.  I am getting an unable to reach area clean self error, but I'm pretty sure that's cause I need another well or ten, since there's only two tiles that can access my current well.

As far as the lye bucket/barrel issue, I usually use magma forges, so I prefer not to burn wood anyways(not an elf or anything, just would rather use the results of my clearcutting for furniture and cages etc), I just embark with 10 to 25 lye, and request it each time from the caravan, and I've never needed to make any. I'm not even sure of all the steps actually.

I'm using the latest release.--[[User:MadGreyOne|MadGreyOne]]
: The "Urist cancels Clean Self: Area Inaccessible" ''is'' the error message spam currently associated with soap. [[User:Niveras|Niveras]] 01:27, 2 December 2010 (UTC)

: Yeah, I'm noticing now, I was confused by the talk about pets carrying soap in their mouth because the mouth was the only part needing cleaned on the dwarfs generating messages. Then I saw some bloody eyeballs etc too. I have still not seen it from pets, but I'm using cages to keep FPS up so maybe I'm just missing them. Hmmm, makes me wonder if dwarfs have an aversion to washing thier mouths out with soap. I know I wouldn't want to. Great, now we need toothpaste too. Come on guys, you're dwarves that blood in your mouth, that's for next time you get thirsty, haven't you ever gone adventuring. --[[User:MadGreyOne|MadGreyOne]]

I wasn't getting these messages but I've started getting them. It's obviously associated with specific dirty areas.--[[Special:Contributions/58.122.40.118|58.122.40.118]] 13:38, 6 December 2010 (UTC)

==Imported lye==
It seems that when I get traders to bring me lye they bring it in stacks of then in a barrel (i.e. lye [10]). Unfortunately the create soap job seems to use the whole stack of 10, while when I make lye myself the lye never stacks and each job only uses one unit. I just thought I'd put this somewhere in case someone cares. Also if someone wants to verify that I'm not just insane that would be nice. --[[User:Dapanman|Dapanman]] 01:07, 10 April 2011 (UTC)

: Confirmed.  It's been doing this for me for the last 5 or so releases.  I haven't checked homemade lye yet (due to a huge lack of coal, meaning my trees go to more important things), but for imported lye the stack gets used up all at once, only to make a single unit of soap.  Also, I've only done this recently with rock nut oil, not tallow, but the first time I tried, I used tallow and got the same results.  --[[Special:Contributions/68.232.113.106|68.232.113.106]] 12:50, 10 April 2011 (UTC)

:: As far as I remember, homemade lye comes in one unit per stack. In any case, this works as expected. [[User:Qwertyu|Qwertyu]] 17:05, 10 April 2011 (UTC)

::: Still exists in .25. The workaround I use is a lye-only food stockpile with barrels disabled. Buckets of one lye each will be stockpiled there, and they work just fine for potash/soap production --[[Special:Contributions/69.151.63.186|69.151.63.186]] 19:41, 12 April 2011 (UTC)

:::: Will your dwarves split imported (lye [10]) into stacks of 1 in order to store them in buckets? Or are speaking strictly of homemade lye? If they split the stacks this is a pretty important workaround. I will try it out next time I get a chance (though if I am completely honest I rarely have success with lye stockpiles anyway). --[[User:Dapanman|Dapanman]] 18:52, 14 April 2011 (UTC)

::::: No luck on barrels of lye[10] from the caravan. I never did figure out a way to get more than one useable lye from those, so once armed with the no-barrels stockpile homemade method I quit ordering it. For best results I'd suggest 
:::::*1) place ashery/soapery/tallow stockpile near each other, yet out of the way relative to the fort itself 
:::::*2) a small 3-4 square bucket-only furniture stockpile near the ashery (additionally have a main bucket stockpile near the water supply, and have *more* buckets than both stockpiles can hold, so that there will always be empty buckets available at the ashery (buckets with a few units of water that are useless for lye production won't be stockpiled)
:::::*3)a small 6-8 square food stockpile, near the soapery, allowing zero barrels, that is the *only* stockpile in your fort accepting lye

:::::http://i.imgur.com/nC7va.jpg

:::::--[[Special:Contributions/69.152.174.177|69.152.174.177]] 03:17, 21 April 2011 (UTC)

==Hospital storage==
I can't get my dorfs to store soap (made from homemade lye and tallow) in the hospital zone. It just stays at the soapmaker's workshop, cluttering it, and the hospital shows 0 soap. Googling it yielded an old bug where soap was made into globs and not bars, which prevented it from being used and which was fixed in release 31.02 (I'm using 31.25). My workshops produce bars of soap, but apart from that it looks similar. Has anyone else encountered this?
         i got something similarin in wich my soap bars are in just sitting a stcokpile 
         and in the hospital the supply is zero even when i create a soap only stockpile in    the hostpital zone it doesnt show up in the information
:Yes, also in 31.25, not having any luck getting dwarves to move soap.

Are you sure that you have enough containers (chests) in your hospital?  Your dwarves only move (some types?) of supplies to the hospital if they can put them in a built chest when they get there.  Note that cabinets do not count as containers in my experience (31.25).  My hospital did have soap added to it after adding the chests.

== Some idea I had ==

I think that maybe there could be some way to correct the problem with the whole lye creation and else. If Toady One can find the part where the lye-making is described, maybe he could add some kind of tag that "reads" if a bucket has water in it: if it does, then it doesn't use the bucket, or it takes the bucket and dumps the water.

== Forgotten beast soap ==

He he he, any one got this?


yep, From a giant flying tick that went down easy like chocolate, and then caused half my military to choke to death due to a blood syndrome.

:You're looking at the wrong page -- ticks were introduced in 0.34, and this page is about 0.31. &mdash;[[User:Lethosor|<span style="color:#074">Lethosor</span>]] ([[User talk:Lethosor|<span style="color:#092">talk</span>]]) 04:27, 15 March 2014 (UTC)